Fatzo`s Sub and Pizza Shop in Two Rivers

Food was good, but when busy they don't have a good system to handle the volume.

Small place, carry out or dine in. Friendly staff. Great food for the price. Average menu item $5.50-10.00

Really good food and very nice staff.

Best pizza we have ever eaten!!

Great thin crust pizza, service isn't the greatest though

It is really good and you get good sized portions and the price is perfect for what you get.

Great staff, amazing food

The best subs and pizza.

The picture explains it all. This is suppose to be a half a chicken breast sub? Two of the thinnest what appeared to be slices of chicken breast topped with fragments of wilted lettuce, a few specs of tomato and onion on a dried out bun. $6.00 and the dog wouldn't even eat it. This has to be the grosses excuse for food that I've ever encountered. Also the local free Cool City WiFi which is right outside the door doesn't work there. Seems like the city doesn't even care about this place.

Slow. Slow. Slow. Everytime I come in it takes at least 10min to get a cold or hot sub. Today i ordered a sub and waited 20 min wasn't even busy.. Had to go back to work so i didn't even get to eat lunch since i was still waiting.. also the chicken subs are gross. The chicken breast used isn't very good. Same kinda junk you get at subway. I've worked at a pizza/sub shop before in a bigger city with 2 people working. It shouldn't take longer than 10 minutes no matter what.

We were told by a couple of friends that Fatzo's in Two Rivers was a must get when we visited Fox Hills Resort! Let me say I am not in the least disappointed... the subs are Huuuuggggeeee and full of heavenly goodness! The owner is great as well! Great personality and just down right personable! Highly recommend a stop at Fatzo's when ever your in the Two Rivers area.. though I'm told theres one in Sturgeon Bay as well! Two Rivers is where it all started though- Great Subs with a Great Price! WTG Fatzo's & crew!

Usually very good, but was put off by young workers not wearing hair nets, gloves and especially no face mask while there's a pandemic going on.

Great sandwiches wish they were closer to my house

We had supper from there on Friday june21. Good food but I had the club salad & they forgot to put the bacon on. Also no salad dressing sent along.Hubbys sandwich was good. Next time we order I will e checking our order.

Outstanding subs.

Ordered a taco salad. Really bad. I don't enjoy hair in my food. Lost a customer. 😡😡😡

Great subs n pizza

This is one of the two places that I tell people, who visiting the area, they absolutely have to eat at before they leave town. Subs are huge, but they go down so easily. It's all in the bread. Try one and you'll know what I mean!

Terrible customer service. I usually recommend to everyone, but have had a terrible experience. The staff saying I was cussing at them on new years Eve because they were closed twenty minutes ago. We spents $50 and ended up with this.

Been going to Fatzo’s for over 20 years. They have always been excellent! They have always remained consistent over all this time, even when owners have changed. I recommend the Super Fatzo.

The pizza is delicious! But they may be victims of their own success when it comes to service (they can get quite busy and overwhelmed with orders). I will likely return, but will never ever order ahead again (because none of the employees know me).If you’re a regular and they know you, it’s great, but I f not, just show up and order at the counter. I ordered ahead and when I showed up, they sheepishly told me that other orders were bumped ahead of mine “even though they shouldn’t have been”. At least they ‘fessed up. 🙄Yes, it messed up my schedule, but at least I got a good pizza (sadly, they didn’t even offer any kind of freebie for my wait).

I know this place quite well, My Grandfather used to own the building. The store years ago was Two Rivers Linoleum and Carpet Shop. Now Fatzo’s is a very good place to order out, They Deliver. Excellent food excellent staff and excellent prices.

Subs great delivery fast but Pricey lady manager was very very very rude to me! I love food but not coming back.... Disrespect can do alot

Great food great prices friendly staff

I was at a class and one of the other class members made a list and ran to get subs for some of us. I wasn't sure about what to get because I had never been here. I just picked The Hog. This was the smaller size sub. I COULDN'T BELIEVE the size of this sub for only $4.95! It was huge and excellent quality. My sub was almost the size of a competitive chain's large sub. I'm certainly going to stop in. UPDATE: I followed Google maps and couldn't find it. I called and they hung up on me. Drove around and found it a couple blocks further. I had the same sub. Maybe I was hungrier a week ago, but it wasn't as good. I had very fast service and found out somebody was trying to do call waiting with the phone????

Been going to Fatzo’s for over 20 years. Always been great! Always been consistent all these years.

Not even comparable to old fatzos taco salad no taco flavor

I drive from Appleton to Two Rivers just to get subs from this place. The drive is worth it because the food is fantastic. Maybe I'm addicted lol.

You can’t visit TR without going to Fatzo’s! Are they the best subs and pizza in the world? Nah, but does it hit the spot every single time? Absolutely. Love the meatball, hot pork and pizza subs. The garlic bread with cheese is also freaking wonderful. Wish I had a Fatzo's down in Florida!

Used to be super super yummy! But these past couple years has gone very down hill. Anytime I’d go in the younger employees would kind of suck around and the older employees would be working and just kind of ignoring them.

Nice little place with a fun atmosphere and good food. (Ordered the Fatzo supreme pizza)

Delicious but the wait is very long and service is ok but food is amazing

Its a local place in my hometown. I grew up going there. Best subs anywhere

This place has awesome homemade food yummy amazing size for your buck !! Pizza is delicious !!! Friendly, clean and they deliver to Tapawingo road !!’ We love you guys thanks you for everything 😍

Their food has always been very good. I’ve noticed it has declined in the past two years, but it’s still very good. I’m not sure if it’s the bread or the meats, but something is definitely different. Aside from that (which is minor), the prices are reasonable, food is ready quickly, and the staff is kind. It’s been a long-time Two Rivers institution for a reason. Good stuff. I recommend the Fatzo sub or the BLT sub.

The best subs you will get anywhere.

Delicious sandwiches. A good place to pickup and go. Can eat inside, but small.

Always great at the one and only

Food was not the greatest. And service slow. Everything went downhill in Two Rivers place.

Always delicious! Great value!

Always a great place to get food. I walked in off the street and ordered four different subs for my family and I, and they were ready fairly quick. I had the corned beef (my favorite), my wife the gyro, one son the meatball, and the last had a Little Oscar (served on a footlong hotdog bun). Delicious food and polite service; what more could you ask for?

The pizza was super salty and the restaurant was messy. The person doing the cash register was wearing the same gloves that he had on when taking out the garbage.

Mediocre food. Outdated decor. Icky bathroom

Best subs hands down!

Great food and service

Subs are nasty! There never the same made when delivered. And there pizza is nasty compared to Luigi's and Hazel's pizza! Two Rivers best food spots is Hazel's and Luigi's!

Have always loved Fatzo's. Today was no exception. Called in order, got there in less than 10 minutes (7 to be exact) and food was ready and fantastic. From call to out the door....less than 10 minutes. Great job!!!

Very tasty pizzas and subs.

Best subs around

Footlong hot dog is not a foot, bun was dry and hard and was smashed, hot dog was rubbery. Nacho's had almost no cheese on it and was luke warm. Not impressed. Most likely will not return.